California voters rejected Proposition 40, a proposed one-time 5% tax on the state’s billionaires, according to an Associated Press determination reported on November 10, 2026. The result came despite Democratic gains in the midterm elections. Economists who disagreed about the measure’s likely economic effects also disagree about why it lost.
UC Berkeley economist Gabriel Zucman, a supporter of wealth taxes, argued that opposition spending was critical. Opponents spent almost $400 million fighting Proposition 40, including spending on competing ballot measures. Zucman said they spent more than $300 million on ads, while the measure’s supporters spent comparatively little. In his view, that imbalance could have been pivotal in a close vote.
Stanford economist Joshua Rauh, a critic of Proposition 40, questioned whether advertising explains the result. He pointed to Bay Area counties where support for the measure fell particularly far below Kamala Harris’s support in the 2024 presidential election. Rauh argued that voters in those areas may have been more skeptical because of their proximity to billionaires and the businesses they fund. Neither economist’s interpretation establishes a definitive cause of the defeat.
The measure’s design also drew opposition. It would have directed 90% of its projected revenue to health care and the remaining 10% to food assistance and education-related programs. The California Teachers Association opposed it, arguing that it shortchanged public schools and would not provide lasting funding. Governor Gavin Newsom also opposed the state-level measure, saying in June that he favored pursuing a minimum tax on billionaires at the federal level instead.
Zucman expects wealth-tax proposals to remain prominent in the next Congress. Rauh also expects further proposals but sees little chance of a federal measure becoming law soon. He additionally argues that a federal wealth tax would face constitutional restrictions on “direct taxes”; legal scholars disagree about whether those restrictions would apply. Proposition 40’s defeat therefore settles the California vote, not the wider debate over wealth taxes.
