At a Senate Budget Committee hearing on November 18, 2026, Chairman Ron Johnson, a Wisconsin Republican, called Social Security “a legal Ponzi scheme.” The exchange, reported on November 19, brought renewed attention to the program’s projected funding shortfall and to what lawmakers might do about it.
Johnson argued in a hearing memo that Social Security resembles a Ponzi scheme if the word “fraud” is removed from the Securities and Exchange Commission’s definition. Experts cited in the report disputed the comparison, pointing to a program financed mainly by payroll taxes, with past surpluses invested in special U.S. Treasury securities held by its trust funds.
Earlier that day, Johnson told Fox Business there was “really no way to fix Social Security” and said, “You can’t fix it, you just shut it down.” At the hearing, he said those remarks were “imprecise”: he had been speaking about Ponzi schemes generally, not calling for Social Security to be shut down. Senator Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat, had characterized the interview differently, saying Johnson appeared to prefer shutting down the program to fixing it.
Johnson said he wanted legislation to prevent cuts to seniors’ benefits before addressing broader federal deficits. He proposed a bill that would fund Social Security retirement benefits from general revenue once the retirement trust fund is depleted. That was a proposal, not an enacted change. Maya MacGuineas, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, argued that using general revenue would sharply increase federal debt; she estimated a cost equal to 165% of gross domestic product over 75 years. Separately, the Congressional Budget Office projected a cumulative federal budget deficit of $24.4 trillion over the next decade.
The Social Security trustees projected in June that the retirement trust fund could be depleted in the fourth quarter of 2032. At that point, continuing income would cover an estimated 78% of scheduled retirement benefits. The combined retirement and disability trust funds were projected to be depleted in the third quarter of 2034, when 83% of scheduled benefits would be payable. Depletion would not mean that all benefits stop, but it would leave a gap unless lawmakers act.
Bill Sweeney of AARP said Social Security operates on its own budget and cannot borrow. The fiscal accounting is more nuanced: according to the CBO, when Social Security outlays exceed dedicated revenues, the program affects the unified federal deficit and debt held by the public. Treasury securities in its trust funds count toward gross federal debt, but not debt held by the public.
Witness Jason Fichtner, executive director of the LIMRA Retirement Income Institute, said changes such as raising or eliminating the payroll-taxable maximum could delay the funding problem without necessarily meeting the program’s 75-year solvency target. He also warned that fear about the trust funds could lead people to claim benefits earlier. A June 2025 AARP survey found that 49% of respondents who had recently claimed, or planned to claim, earlier than intended were mostly motivated by concern that Social Security might run out of money.

